{"connections":[],"files":[{"byte_length":1671,"caption_url":"","derived_from":null,"display_filename":"RCL-789-reading.txt","filename":"RCL-789-reading.txt","id":"d321a4ad-ede6-40c6-88d6-ad837238fd14","ingested_at":"2026-11-08T17:15:10.291708+00:00","is_audio":false,"is_image":false,"is_public":true,"is_video":false,"kind":"supporting","media_url":"/media/d321a4ad-ede6-40c6-88d6-ad837238fd14","meta":{"basis_version":"","caption_asset_id":"","caption_label":"","caption_language":"","duration_label":"","format_note":"UTF-8 text","language":"en","page_count_label":"1","produced_by":"Crypt of Echoes (independent reading)","production_note":"Independent local reading of the complete written face of Huntington Library manuscript HM 21873. Authorship is disputed: the manuscript has been identified as a forgery, while later editors discuss evidence that leaves the judgment contested. This record preserves the disputed document as a research object and does not certify Poe as its author. It is excluded from the verified correspondence map. The public file is text only; the modern reference image remains private. Line wrapping, superscripts and decorative underlines are simplified. No separate address face is supplied.","review_state":"Known limitations","rights_note":"The underlying document was reproduced in the 1920 Clawson sale catalogue, item 346, and its text printed in Mary E. Phillips, Edgar Allan Poe: The Man (1926), volume 2, pp. 1403–1404. This independently prepared reading includes new descriptive notes by Crypt of Echoes. The 2008 edition’s commentary, transcription and image are not redistributed.","role":"transcript","title":"Local reading — disputed attribution","transcript_asset_id":""},"mime":"text/plain","published_version":1,"role_label":"Transcription","sha256":"f5c9fda5ee95499b51603c02c4cf49fa98eaf366a4c2ad866cff0e76e22ef009","size_label":"1.6 KB","type_label":"Text","working_version":0}],"format":"crypt-of-echoes-public-manifest-v3","generated_at":"2026-11-11T07:09:51.324339595+00:00","integrity_notice":"SHA-256 permits comparison with these recorded bytes. It does not establish source authenticity, truth, capture time, or independent timestamp certification.","permalink":"https://cryptofechoes.com/evidence/LED-2026-db8b813d47a544299142a151eca804ba","record":{"created_at":"2026-11-08T17:15:05.766062+00:00","e":{"access_note":"Complete written-face reading hosted locally as searchable text. Reference photograph private. No local manuscript facsimile claimed.","account_id":"","acquisition":"Owner-authorized preservation of a distinct disputed document with transparent attribution.","bibliographic_citation":"Letter attributed to Edgar Allan Poe to John R. Thompson, dated May 10, 1849. Huntington Library, HM 21873. Authorship disputed. Clawson sale, November 29, 1920, item 346 (facsimile); Mary E. Phillips, Edgar Allan Poe: The Man (1926), volume 2, pp. 1403–1404. Manuscript reference: The Collected Letters of Edgar Allan Poe (2008), illustration 59, made available by the Edgar Allan Poe Society of Baltimore.","call_number":"HM 21873; RCL-789; LTR-313","capture_method":"Independent visual transcription from the public manuscript facsimile; reference JPEG preserved unchanged and private.","captured_at":"2026-11-08T17:08:21+00:00","collection_ids":["edgar-allan-poe"],"completeness":"Independent local reading of the complete written face of Huntington Library manuscript HM 21873. Authorship is disputed: the manuscript has been identified as a forgery, while later editors discuss evidence that leaves the judgment contested. This record preserves the disputed document as a research object and does not certify Poe as its author. It is excluded from the verified correspondence map. The public file is text only; the modern reference image remains private. Line wrapping, superscripts and decorative underlines are simplified. No separate address face is supplied.","condition_note":"Authorship disputed. Small grayscale reference image; decorative marks and precise layout are not reproduced.","context":"Independent local reading of the complete written face of Huntington Library manuscript HM 21873. Authorship is disputed: the manuscript has been identified as a forgery, while later editors discuss evidence that leaves the judgment contested. This record preserves the disputed document as a research object and does not certify Poe as its author. It is excluded from the verified correspondence map. The public file is text only; the modern reference image remains private. Line wrapping, superscripts and decorative underlines are simplified. No separate address face is supplied.","contributors":"Unknown or disputed author; Crypt of Echoes (independent reading)","date_label":"1849-05-10","edition":"Independent reading of a disputed manuscript, historically printed by 1926","entity_ids":["edgar-allan-poe-person"],"exact_quote":"","identifiers":"Crypt Poe gap intake 2026-11; RCL-789","issue":"","kind":"Manuscript or letter","language":"English","license":"Public-domain historical document; independent local reading. Modern source edition excluded from public downloads.","location":"","organization":"","original_title":"Disputed letter attributed to Edgar Allan Poe to John R. Thompson — May 10, 1849","pages":"1 complete written face represented in reading","parent_url":"https://www.eapoe.org/papers/misc1921/mep2cb07.htm","person":"Edgar Allan Poe (attributed; disputed); John Reuben Thompson","place_ids":[],"publication_place":"New York (as dated on document)","publisher":"","repository":"The Huntington Library","rights_note":"The underlying document was reproduced in the 1920 Clawson sale catalogue, item 346, and its text printed in Mary E. Phillips, Edgar Allan Poe: The Man (1926), volume 2, pp. 1403–1404. This independently prepared reading includes new descriptive notes by Crypt of Echoes. The 2008 edition’s commentary, transcription and image are not redistributed.","source_platform":"Edgar Allan Poe Society of Baltimore; source manuscript at Huntington Library","source_published_at":"","source_url":"https://www.eapoe.org/works/ostlttrs/pl082i59.htm","subject_ids":["history","literature"],"summary":"Read a complete local transcription of the disputed May 10, 1849 letter to John R. Thompson concerning Marginalia and a manuscript of The Raven. Authorship remains unresolved; this item is excluded from the verified Poe correspondence map.","title":"Disputed letter attributed to Edgar Allan Poe to John R. Thompson — May 10, 1849","topics":"","verification":"Not independently verified","verification_notes":"Written face, date, addressee, signature and HM 21873 call number visually inspected. Checklist key, date/correspondent and text overlap checked against holdings. Historical 1926 printing checked. Attribution remains disputed.","volume":""},"id":"LED-2026-db8b813d47a544299142a151eca804ba","published_version":1,"status":"published","version":1},"research_questions":[]}